Resources for Implementing PTIE on Your Campus
PTIE Workbook with GAP analysis and Action Plan (View PDF).
Internal Survey you can use to gauge interest at your university (Download Word Document), (View PDF of Word Document).
I&E Summary of Additions (approved June 2023) (View PDF) explains all the specific rule changes.
I&E P&T Presentation-Post EC.2023.05.05 (Download Slide Deck), (View PDF of Slide Deck). This was presented to faculty senate.
I&E P&T Timeline Document-June meeting (View PDF) timeline summary of all the work we did at OSU to communicate PTIE efforts.
Charge for I&E P&T Committee_2019 (View PDF) – original charge (pre-COVID) to create a campus committee to investigate this topic.
Useful data on innovation (both student and alumni perspective) (View PDF).
Sanberg et al. (2014) PNAS paper (View PDF) documenting benefits to engaging with industry.
Science paper (View PDF) documenting the PTIE effort.
2020 OSU Video on Innovation, Entrepreneurship and Societal Impact (View Video).
A one-page “cheat sheet” of P&T metrics from OHSU (View PDF).
For I&E metrics, please see page 5 of the attached recommendations. (View PDF) You can see an example of how they got implemented on OSU’s Faculty Handbook.
A sample CV from our College of Ag with I&E incorporated. (Download Word Document), (View PDF of Word Document).
Spring 2025 PTIE presentation (Download Slide Deck), (View PDF of Slide Deck).
Fall 2025 PTIE presentation (Download Slide Deck)
Suggested Early, Mid and Long-term metrics to track progress at culture change around translation on your campus (PDF file)
PTIE Publications
PTIE Findings: Expanding Promotion and Tenure Guidelines to Inclusively Recognize Innovation and Entrepreneurial Impact (View PDF).
Carter, R. G.; Mundorff, K.; Risien, J.; Bouwma-Gearhart, J.; Bratsch-Prince, D.; Brown, S. A., Campbell, A. L.; Hartman, J. C.; Hasemann, C. A.; Hollenbeck, P. J.; Lupiani, B.; McCarty, O. J. T.; McClure, I. D.; Mealey, K.; Mimura, C.; Romero, A. J.; Sztajn, P.; Van Egeren, L. "Innovation, entrepreneurship, promotion, and tenure." Science 2021, 373, 1312-1314. Abstract
Bouwma-Gearhart, J.; Lenhart, C.; Carter, R.; Mundorff, K.; Cho, H.; Knoch, J. Inclusively Recognizing Faculty Innovation and Entrepreneurship Impact within Promotion and Tenure Considerations. J. Open Innov. Technol. Mark. Complex. 2021, 7, 182. Abstract
Bouwma-Gearhart, J.; Carter, R. Mundorff, K. (2021) "A Call For Promoting Faculty Innovation and Entrepreneurship." Change 2021, 53 (2), 18-24. Abstract
Kohs, T.C.L., Clarin, S.N., Carter, R.G. et al. “Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Promotion and Tenure in Biomedical Engineering: Communication from the Biomedical Engineering Society Long Range Planning Committee.” Cel. Mol. Bioeng. 16, 181–185 (2023). Abstract
2020 National Conference Materials
This conference was held virtually September 16-18, 2020. Representatives from the United States met to finalize PTIE recommendations, share their latest work and learn from each other.
Webinars:
September 16, 2020 – Video (54 min) Introduction and Overview of PTIE Effort, Summary of 2019 Survey Findings, Review of Recommendations from Small Group on Metrics and Language.
September 17, 2020 – Video (2 hour, 30 min) Introduction and Overview of PTIE Effort, Review of Outcomes from Day 1 Session, Review of Recommendations from Small Group on Process Changes and Diversity, Panel Discussion: The Interoperability Opportunity of Innovation and Entrepreneurship and Diversity, Equity and Inclusion in the Promotion and Tenure Process, Panel Discussion: Process Changes in Support of Inclusively Recognizing Innovation and Entrepreneurship in Promotion and Tenure, Review of Day 2, Preview of Day 3 and Reminder about Voting.
Documents:
Inclusive Recognition of I&E in P&T Implementation Process (September 19, 2020) PTIE Inclusive Recognition (PDF File)
Presentation Slide Decks:
“The Relationship of CEO Gender and Age to Performance of Venture-Backed Startups.” Carol Mimura, California Berkley, PTIE Panelist (September 17, 2020) PTIE Slide Deck (PDF File)
“Changing Attitudes through P&T Committee Training: A Pilot Process.” Dawn Bratsch-Prince, Iowa State University, PTIE Panelist (September 17, 2020)
PTIE Slide Deck (PDF File)“Current Practices in the P&T Process at Jackson State University.” Almesha L. Campbell, Jackson State University, PTIE Panelist (September 17, 2020)
PTIE Slide Deck (PDF File)Introduction to the OSU Search Advocate Program, Anne Gillies, Oregon State University, PTIE Panelist (September 17, 2020), Introductory Video (4 min).
PTIE Slide Deck (PDF File)
2022 National Conference Materials
This conference was held July 25-27, 2022 at Skamania Lodge in Stevenson, WA. Representatives from the United States and Canada met to share their latest work and learn from each other.
Welcome and Framing for Morning Session (view PDF of proceedings) by Rich G. Carter
Keynote Presentation (view PDF of proceedings) by Erwin Gianchandani (Assistant Director for Technology, Innovation and Partnerships, National Science Foundation)
APLUs Public Impact Research (PIR) and Connections to PTIE. (view PDF of proceedings) Panel Discussion with panelist Sandra Brown (University of California at San Diego), Laurie Van Egeren (APLU & Michigan State University), Randy Hall (University of Southern California)
NSFs I-Corps: Aligning Incentives & Entrepreneurship in Academia. (view PDF of proceedings) Panel Discussion with Dedric Carter (Washington University – St. Louis), Pamela McCauley (North Carolina State University), Rebecca Shearman (National Science Foundation), Karl Mundorff – Moderator (Oregon State University)
VentureWell: A facilitated conversation regarding how promotion and tenure policies impact early-stage innovator development. (view PDF of proceedings) Chithra Adams(VentureWell)
Keynote Presentation (view PDF of proceedings) by Pamela McCauley (Associate Dean for Academic Programs, Diversity, Equity and Inclusion, North Carolina State University)
Swimming Across the Stream – Developing a Generation of Boundary-Spanning Faculty for Innovation and Entrepreneurship (view PDF of proceedings) James McLellan, Elicia Maine, & Sarah Lubik
Ball State University: Beneficence and P&T (view PDF of proceedings) Kecia McBride and Susana River-Mills
Analysis of the Role of NSF I-Corps Training on Engineering and Science Faculty Retention Rates at CUNY (view PDF of proceedings) Jessica Fields & Nhi Tran
Examining I&E Language in External Review Letters (view PDF of proceedings) Ebenezer Edema-Sillo & Francisco J Torres III
Modernizing the Relationship between Academia and the Public (view PDF of proceedings) Mary Woolley
PTIE: Reflections on University Strategic Planning & Holistic Faculty Evaluation (view PDF of proceedings) Bahman Shahri, Blanca Lupiani & Heather Wilkinson
Being Innovative at Arizona State University (view PDF of proceedings) Deborah Clarke
Accelerating Public Access to Research Data (APARD): A Guide for Change in Research Universities (view PDF of proceedings) Kacy Redd, Sarah Nusser, Tobin Smith, & Emily Miller
White Paper for the New President of NJIT from the NJIT Faculty Senate Research Committee (view PDF of proceedings) Michael Ehrlich
NSF I-Corps Inclusion Summit: A Model for Increasing Awareness of the Value of I&E (view PDF of proceedings) Ariella Trotsenko & Cira Cardaci
Modernizing Scholarship for the Public Good (view PDF of proceedings) Elyse L Aurbach, Kacy Redd, & Howard Gobstein
Incentivizing Impact Through Innovation: An International Review of University Policies (view PDF of proceedings) Randolph Hall, Annicka Caprariello, & Amber Patel
Innovation Training and PTIE: a service-wrapped approach to professional development in support of PTIE implementation (view PDF of proceedings) Ian McClure (Associate Vice President for Research, University of Kentucky)